Resources: Compare

#789, v1.0 Published:
#439, v1.0 Published:

Title

Old VersionNew Version
1A Pipeline in Paradise, Part 1: Learning the Relevant Science 1A Pipeline in Paradise

Authors

Old VersionNew Version
1Shannon N. Conley (James Madison University) 1Fred L Nesbitt ()
2Kathryn De Ridder-Vignone (James Madison University) 2Gabriela Hamerlinck (QUBES, BioQUEST)
3Mary K. Handley (James Madison University)   
4Michael L. Deaton (James Madison University)   
5Deborah Rook () 3Deborah Rook () 
  4Cynthia Wei () 
  5Gautam Sethi () 
  6Gulnihal Ozbay () 
  7Hayley Orndorf (University of Pittsburgh) 
  8Victoria Schneider () 
  9Victoria Schneider () 

Description

Old VersionNew Version
1<p>his case study focuses on the people and landscape of Madison County, VA, through which Spectra Energy wishes to route a natural gas pipeline that runs from the Marcellus shale hydraulic fracturing wells in Pennsylvania to Duke Power&rsquo;s generating plans in North Carolina. The case provides a rich context for students to explore the natural science, political context, and social dynamics associated with hydraulic fracturing and with that community&rsquo;s decision and power to permit (or not permit) the pipeline. &nbsp;</p>  1<p>This Qubes Resource is a modification of A Pipeline in Paradise Part 1 Case Study.&nbsp; I developed a Power Point presentation for the case study instead of using the video.&nbsp; I also changed the case study to include fracking (not just building a pipeline through the area).&nbsp; This enabled us to discuss fracking.&nbsp;</p>
2  2  
3<p>The &ldquo;hook&rdquo; is a story about a real-life centenarian landowner named Culton Goodall, who owns a beautiful farm on the proposed pipeline route. Mr. Goodall&rsquo;s family has owned this farm for generations. Their care and love for the land is evident by their progressive and sustainable land use practices. The story opens when Mr. Goodall is visited by a Spectra Energy representative who requests permission to survey the farm and evaluate the feasibility of the pipeline. Students are are introduced to Mr. Goodall, his land, and the beautiful landscape around Madison county via a recorded 8 minute video created by Mr. Goodall&rsquo;s son, Paul (a faculty member in JMU&rsquo;s Department of Integrated Science and Technology).&nbsp; The video ends by posing the question: &ldquo;What should Mr. Goodall do?&rdquo;</p>  3<p>I followed this format:</p>
4  4  
5<p>This is the first part of a larger 3-part case study in which each step guides students through three different types of analyses of this problem. This current case (Part 1) requires students to integrate information across the following five &ldquo;knowledge domains&rdquo; to develop a baseline understanding of the problem: (1) technology and natural science, (2) environmental issues, (3) governance, (4) national energy security, and (5) society. Students gain a more complex understanding of the problem by learning how to interpret knowledge from different disciplines, make connections across domains, and evaluate sometimes conflicting perspectives.</p> 5<ul>
   6   <li>I lecture about what fracking is and why it is done.&nbsp;</li>
   7   <li>Then I give each student a worksheet that has EITHER the benefits or dangers of fracking.&nbsp; They read the worksheet and there is a question at the bottom that asks, based on what you have read, would you support or not support fracking?&nbsp;</li>
   8   <li>Then they have to find a student who had the opposing worksheet (so if you had benefits, you find someone who had dangers) and then you tell the person what you learned.&nbsp;</li>
   9   <li>Then we discuss positives and negatives as a class and put them on the board.</li>
   10   <li>Next I presented the Power Point with the case study information.</li>
   11   <li>After that, they do the activity which involves them working in a group and brainstorming questions from the point of view of the farmer.&nbsp;</li>
   12   <li>Then they brainstorm questions from the point of view of the county government.</li>
   13   <li>Finally they get an assignment to write a memo from the point of view of a citizen of the county to either support or not support inviting the energy company into the county.&nbsp; They must use some kind of data to support their argument.&nbsp; (We looked at graphs of earthquake increases and we looked at job growth from fracking).&nbsp;</li>
   14</ul>